A discussion: AI and homework
Nadia and Theo present their school’s podcast. This week they talk about the school’s new rules on using AI chatbots for homework.
Listen for each speaker’s opinion and how it changes. Notice when they agree, when they only partly agree, and when they don’t agree at all.
Exercises
The school podcast: AI and homework
Two students record an episode of their school’s podcast.
Read the text
Listen first. Then read to check what you heard.
- Theo:
- So, Nadia, the school's just changed its rules on AI. What did you make of the announcement?
- Nadia:
- Honestly, I was relieved. Before, nobody knew what was allowed. Half the class were using chatbots secretly, and the other half felt stupid for not using them. At least now we're all playing by the same rules.
- Theo:
- I'm not sure relieved is how I'd put it. I think the new rules are pretty vague. Use AI responsibly. What does that actually mean?
- Nadia:
- Fair point. But they did give examples. You can ask it to explain something you didn't get in class, but you can't hand in anything it's written.
- Theo:
- Right, and that's my problem. Where's the line? If it tells me how to structure an essay, and I follow that exactly, is the essay still mine?
- Nadia:
- I'd say yes, as long as the ideas and the words are yours. It's not that different from a teacher giving you feedback.
- Theo:
- Except a teacher doesn't make things up. Last month I asked one of these tools for sources for my history project, and two of the books it gave me didn't exist. I only noticed because the library couldn't find them.
- Nadia:
- Oh, that's happened to me too, with a quote. It sounded so confident. That's why I think the skill we actually need isn't avoiding AI. It's checking it.
- Theo:
- Hmm, I'm with you on that. But here's what worries me more. Homework's supposed to be practice. If something does the hard part for you, you don't get the practice. It's like paying someone else to go to the gym for you.
- Nadia:
- I like that comparison, but I don't think it's always true. When I'm stuck on a maths problem at eleven at night, there's nobody to ask. A hint means I keep going instead of giving up. That's still practice.
- Theo:
- A hint, sure. But be honest. How many people stop at a hint?
- Nadia:
- Not many, probably. Which is maybe an argument for changing the homework, not banning the tool. If a chatbot can do a task in five seconds, maybe it wasn't a great task in the first place.
- Theo:
- That's a bit convenient for students, isn't it? The homework's bad, so it doesn't matter if we cheat.
- Nadia:
- That's not what I'm saying at all! I mean more homework like presentations, or explaining your answer out loud in class. Things that show you really understand.
- Theo:
- OK, that I'd agree with. Our English teacher already does it. She asks you questions about your essay, and it's much harder to fake.
- Nadia:
- Exactly. So, final verdict? Good rules or bad rules?
- Theo:
- A good start, I suppose. But I'd give them a year and then ask the students themselves what actually happened, not just the teachers.
- Nadia:
- Now that's something we can agree on.
Press Check answers to see your score.