Skip to content
English Playground
ReadingC1

Phones in schools: four views

Should secondary schools lock mobile phones away all day, trust students to keep them switched off, or put them to work in lessons?

Read four short contributions to a school-community debate and compare how the writers see the same issues from different angles.

Read first

Reading strategy: cross-text matching

In a cross-text matching task, four writers discuss the same set of issues, and you have to work out where two writers share a view or where one writer stands apart from the other three.

Do not match isolated words: two writers may both mention a topic while reaching opposite conclusions about it. Instead, identify the exact issue named in the question, check each writer's overall stance and any conditions or exceptions they add, and verify why the remaining writers disagree.

Text

A — Nadia, Year 12 student council representative

Anyone claiming a phone on silent does no harm is kidding themselves: merely knowing unread messages are sitting in your blazer pocket splits your attention mid-sentence. Even so, heavy-handed confiscations and bag searches always backfire, prompting students to hand in dead spare handsets and breeding resentment across the year group. Keeping phones switched off at the bottom of bags during lessons is a fairer rule, especially as nobody needs family updates in class when the reception desk can pass on any genuine emergency and we still have our phones for dark winter bus rides. At break, though, a quick message helps us reorganise band rehearsals or student council meetings, so policing corridors makes little sense. In class, school-owned laptops beat personal phones, whose cracked screens and chat pop-ups create unequal, distracting tools. Finally, sixth-formers ought to be allowed phones in their study room to practise self-restraint before leaving school.

Text

B — Mr Hollis, secondary history teacher

Tell thirty teenagers to leave phones switched off in their bags and you invite a losing battle; a half-measure like that still tempts covert glances under desks that derail a whole class discussion. Where every colleague applies one clear routine — locking handsets into numbered pouches at morning registration and returning them at the final bell — compliance becomes effortless within a fortnight. Students remain reachable on the walk home, while our office staff pass on urgent daytime messages from parents within minutes. Nor do classrooms lose out academically: looking up a single historical date on a personal phone invites ten distractions, whereas shared school laptops and dictionaries keep minds on the task. Breaktimes have been transformed too, with lively conversation in the yard replacing silent rows of hunched shoulders. Crucially, the rule must cover every year group alike; exempting sixth-formers only fuels complaints lower down the school.

Text

C — Priya, parent of two secondary students

Blaming handsets whenever attention drifts in a classroom is far too convenient: minds wander when teaching is predictable and one-way, and scapegoating screens merely lets uninspiring lessons off the hook. Strict bans are unworkable anyway, because resourceful teenagers effortlessly outwit spot checks while teachers resent acting as security guards. As a parent, I also object to routing daytime messages through a stretched school office; cancelled after-school clubs and rearranged pickups happen at short notice, and a message stuck at reception is useless at four o'clock. Used sensibly, personal phones are genuinely helpful in lessons for checking unfamiliar terms or photographing board diagrams whenever school computers are scarce. Adults shouldn't write off breaktime messaging either — sharing clips and group jokes is simply part of how young people socialise today. And if phones are permitted, eleven-year-olds catching winter buses alone need them every bit as much as sixth-formers.

Text

D — Leo, Year 13 student

I used to defend keeping my phone on my desk, until I noticed how thoroughly an unread notification wrecked my concentration on dense biology chapters. All the same, blanket confiscations achieve very little beyond pushing phones into coat linings and toilet cubicles in an exhausting game of cat and mouse. Older students, especially, shouldn't face the same restrictions as Year 7s: treating seventeen-year-olds like children ignores the independence expected of us at university or work months later. Many of us also juggle medical appointments or collect younger siblings, and queuing at reception to read a parent's text is impractical. That said, when our common room tried screen-free mornings at break, noisy kitchen-table debates quickly replaced silent scrolling, which won me over. Where phones genuinely earn their keep is in lessons themselves — sharing revision flashcards or filming drama rehearsals when school tablets are booked out.

Exercises

  1. Exercise 1: Map one issue across all four writers

    Sort the four writers according to their view on students using phones during breaktimes.

    Tap an item, then press Move here on a group. You can also drag items.

    To sort

    Putting phones away makes breaktimes more sociable

    Nothing here yet.

    Using phones at break has a valid practical or social role

    Nothing here yet.

Press Check answers to see your score.

Keep learning

Next lesson

Wildlife in the city

Read an article on how wild animals adapt to urban life, trace links across whole paragraphs, and restore six removed paragraphs.

C1