Should homework be banned?
Does after-school homework genuinely help teenagers learn, or does it simply take away their evenings?
Read Year 11 student Amir's opinion article for his school magazine, and pay attention to how he builds a balanced argument from everyday school life.
Read first
Purpose, attitude and fact vs opinion
A review gives one person's reaction to an event such as a show. An opinion article does something different: the writer's purpose is to persuade readers to share a view on a wider topic, often by looking at both sides rather than taking a simple yes-or-no view.
As you read, separate facts (details that can be checked, such as times, subjects or actions that happened) from opinions (what the writer thinks, often with words like fair, mistake, deserve or should). Ask yourself why the writer chooses each example.
What should happen to homework? — by Amir, Year 11
Every September, someone at our Year 11 lunch table suggests that homework should be banned altogether, and everyone around the table cheers. After sitting in lessons from quarter to nine until half past three, carrying a heavy bag of folders home on the bus rarely feels welcome. On Tuesdays, my younger sister in Year 8 comes home to tasks in maths, French and geography all due the next morning. By nine o'clock at the kitchen table, she is too tired to take anything in, and everyone at home ends up stressed over a worksheet nobody will remember by Friday.
That frustration is easy to understand when homework is set simply out of habit. Too often, tasks seem designed to fill an hour rather than to help us learn, such as copying long lists of definitions out of a science textbook or decorating a folder cover. Teenagers deserve free evenings to play sport in the park, practise an instrument or eat dinner with their families without worrying about our online school calendar full of deadlines. Spending two hours every night on repetitive exercises does not build real interest; it only teaches students to rush through work just to get it finished.
Even so, getting rid of homework completely would be a mistake, especially for older secondary students. In a busy classroom of thirty people at our school, a forty-five-minute lesson passes quickly, and it is easy to nod along while a teacher explains a maths method on the board without realising what you have missed. When I sit quietly at home and try five questions by myself, I quickly discover where I get stuck. In languages, too, ten minutes of regular vocabulary practice between lessons keeps new words fresh in your head far better than one lesson a week ever could.
Last term, our history department tried a much more sensible approach: teachers replaced long weekly essays with one twenty-minute reading task to prepare us for the next class discussion. Everyone arrived ready to talk about the topic, lessons became livelier, and nobody had to stay up late in front of a blank screen. Instead of banning homework or setting hours of it, schools should set fewer, shorter tasks with a clear purpose. When a task genuinely helps us check today's learning or prepare for tomorrow, twenty focused minutes is a fair deal.
Exercises
Press Check answers to see your score.