A panel discussion: the cities of the future
A radio host asks three guests what cities will be like in 2050: Marcus, an urban planner from the United States; Helen, an architect; and Zak, a nineteen-year-old who campaigns on housing.
The speakers sometimes agree, sometimes disagree, and sometimes only partly agree. Listen for each person’s attitude as well as their ideas, and notice when someone says something you might not expect from them.
Exercises
The cities of 2050
A radio discussion programme.
Read the text
Listen first. Then read to check what you heard.
- Host:
- With me to talk about the cities of the future are Marcus, an urban planner who's worked on smart city projects in the States; Helen, an architect; and Zak, who's nineteen and campaigns on housing. Marcus, picture a city in 2050. What's changed?
- Marcus:
- Honestly, I think the biggest change will be one you can't see. Cities will run on data. Traffic lights that respond to the actual traffic, trash cans that tell the city when they're full, buildings that adjust their heating minute by minute. In some of the districts I've worked on, we've already cut energy use by about a fifth. And frankly, that's just the beginning.
- Host:
- Helen, you're looking doubtful.
- Helen:
- Well, I've sat through a lot of presentations that begin with the words the city of the future, and they tend to feature gleaming new towers and very few actual people. My worry is that we get so excited about building new things that we forget the greenest building is usually the one that already exists. Knocking something down and replacing it, however clever the replacement, releases a huge amount of carbon. So for me, the city of 2050 should look rather like the city of today, just, er, far better used.
- Host:
- Zak, where do you stand?
- Zak:
- Somewhere in between, maybe, but I'm coming at it from a different angle. Whenever a neighbourhood gets greener, with new parks, cycle lanes, all of that, rents tend to go up, and the people who were there first get pushed out. So I'm all for green cities, obviously, but not if they're only green for the people who can afford them.
- Marcus:
- That's a fair challenge, and it's not one technology can solve on its own. But data can help. If you can see exactly who's using a bus route, you're far less likely to cut the one that cleaners and nurses rely on at five in the morning.
- Zak:
- Sure, if someone's looking at the data with that in mind. My point is, it's a political choice, not a technical one.
- Helen:
- I'd go further. I'm uneasy about how much of that data is being collected in the first place. A bin that reports when it's full is one thing. Cameras that track where everyone walks are something else entirely.
- Marcus:
- I don't disagree. In my experience, the projects that work best are the ones where residents decide what's measured. And I'll admit we didn't always get that right early on.
- Host:
- Let's talk about cars. Several cities have already closed their centres to private cars. Is that the future?
- Zak:
- For city centres, absolutely, as long as public transport is cheap and reliable. And you've got to think about people who genuinely need a car, like many disabled residents.
- Helen:
- I agree, and for architects it's a real opportunity. Once you remove car parks, you free up an astonishing amount of space. One study of a mid-sized city found that roughly a third of the centre was given over to parking.
- Marcus:
- I'm a little more cautious there, which might surprise you. Ban cars too fast and local businesses suffer, and then people turn against the whole idea. It needs to happen in stages.
- Host:
- A final thought from each of you. One word for the city of 2050?
- Helen:
- Reused.
- Zak:
- Affordable. Otherwise it isn't a success.
- Marcus:
- Responsive. And, if I can cheat and add a sentence, built with the people who live in it, not just for them.
Press Check answers to see your score.