An essay on two texts: car-free cities
In the C2 Proficiency compulsory essay, you read two short texts of around a hundred words each on the same issue. Your task is not merely to give your opinion: you must summarise the two key points of each text in your own words, evaluate how convincing they are, and reach a reasoned conclusion of your own.
In this lesson, you study two contrasting passages on car-free city centres, practise paraphrasing and academic evaluation, and write a 240–280-word essay.
Explanation
How the two-text essay works
Each input text usually contains two main points. Before you write, underline them and express each one in fresh vocabulary and grammar — for example, turning verbs into noun phrases (people linger → longer pedestrian visits).
A clear four-paragraph structure works reliably:
Paragraph 1 — Introduction: frame the debate briefly in general terms and indicate the tension between the two views.
Paragraph 2 — Text 1 (summary + evaluation): paraphrase both points from Text 1 and assess where the argument is strong or overly optimistic.
Paragraph 3 — Text 2 (summary + evaluation): paraphrase both points from Text 2 and weigh how far its objections hold.
Paragraph 4 — Conclusion: synthesise both sides and state your own balanced position.
Text 1: Reclaiming streets for people
Private cars have dominated historic city centres for far too long, turning shared streets into noisy, polluted corridors. Closing central districts to everyday through-traffic immediately improves air quality and makes cycling or walking to school, libraries and parks far safer. Just as importantly, removing rows of parked vehicles frees valuable space for trees, benches and outdoor seating. Rather than rushing straight from a multi-storey car park into a single shop and driving home again, people linger, meet friends and browse smaller local businesses. Far from harming city centres, pedestrianisation restores them as lively community spaces.
Text 2: Access, fairness and practical reality
Enthusiasm for car-free centres often overlooks those for whom driving is a necessity rather than a habit. Elderly residents, people with limited mobility and families living on poorly served outskirts cannot simply switch to bicycles, especially after dark or in winter weather. Moreover, a working city centre is not merely a leisure park: shops, markets and repair businesses rely on deliveries of heavy goods, and tradespeople need to carry tools. Imposing a blanket ban without reliable public transport only pushes traffic into neighbouring residential streets while making the centre harder for ordinary people to reach.
| Purpose | Useful expressions | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Summarising a view | The first passage contends that …, A central premise of Text 2 is that …, Proponents of … point to … | The first passage contends that cutting traffic revitalises public space. |
| Endorsing a point | rightly draws attention to, makes a compelling case for, is justified in warning that | The writer rightly draws attention to residents with limited mobility. |
| Questioning or qualifying | somewhat overstates, overlooks the fact that, rests on the assumption that, is unduly pessimistic | This claim rests on the assumption that frequent buses already run. |
| Formal linking | While it is undeniable that …, Conversely, Nevertheless, Compelling though this vision is, | Compelling though this vision is, access from outer suburbs still matters. |
Keeping a formal academic register
Maintain an objective, impersonal tone throughout. Avoid contractions (do not, not don't), conversational fillers (loads of, totally unfair), exclamation marks and addressing the reader as you when you mean people in general. Above all, never lift stretches of four or five words unchanged from the input passages.
Exercises
Press Check answers to see your score.