It must be, it can't be: guessing with modals
Why is your friend's coat still hanging in the hallway? Whose trainers are sitting by the gym door? Every day, we use small clues to work out what is true and what happened earlier.
At B1, you used may, might and could for possibility. In this lesson, you add must, can't and couldn't for strong logical guesses — and modal + have + past participle to look back at the past.
Explanation
| How sure you are | Present (now) | Past (earlier) |
|---|---|---|
| Sure it's true | She must be thrilled. | She must have won the race. |
| Possible (maybe) | It might / may / could be Amir's. | He might / may / could have left it here. |
| Possible that … not | They might not / may not know the score. | They might not / may not have heard the bell. |
| Sure it's impossible | That can't / couldn't be right. | You can't / couldn't have seen Marco — he's in Italy! |
Guessing about the present
When clues make you almost certain that something is true right now, use must + base verb: You've carried that heavy rucksack for five miles — your shoulders must ache!
When something is only one possible explanation, use might, may or could + base verb. All three mean the same here: Don't throw that folder away; it might (or may / could) belong to Yasmin.
When clues show that something is impossible, use can't or couldn't + base verb: That can't (or couldn't) be true — the shop is closed on Sundays.
Watch the difference between might not / may not and couldn't / can't: might not means perhaps not, whereas couldn't and can't mean it is impossible. For an action in progress right now, use modal + be + -ing: Nobody is in the kitchen — they must be eating out on the patio.
Guessing about the past: modal + have + past participle
To make a logical guess about something that happened earlier, use must, might, may, could, can't or couldn't + have + past participle.
The garden is covered in fallen branches — there must have been a storm overnight.
I can't find my locker key anywhere. I may have thrown it away with my old notes.
Max can't have broken the window — he was at his gran's all weekend!
Careful: after a modal, always use have (never has or had), and in writing never write of instead of have, even though must've, might've and could've sound like of when spoken.
- Ollie:
- Hang on, someone's left their headphones behind. Whose are they?
- Farah:
- They can't be Mr Patel's — he always uses tiny white earbuds.
- Ollie:
- Could they be Nina's? She was sitting on this side of the studio.
- Farah:
- No, Nina couldn't have brought them today because she was off sick. Wait — didn't Callum have red ones on the bus?
- Ollie:
- You're right! They must belong to Callum. He must have put them down while we were packing the costumes away.
- Farah:
- Let's run to the bike shed — he might not have cycled off yet.
Exercises
Press Check answers to see your score.