Mixed conditionals and the unreal past
Sometimes a single choice last year shapes what you are doing right now: “If I hadn't joined the robotics club, I wouldn't be applying for an engineering placement today.” At other times, who you are now explains a past decision: “If I weren't afraid of heights, I would have signed up for the climbing instructor course.”
You already know how the second conditional imagines the present, how the third conditional looks back at the past, and how wish uses past tenses for unreal ideas. Here you combine those timelines in mixed conditionals, add but for and should you…, and use the unreal past after it's time, would rather and as if.
Explanation
Mixed conditionals: crossing past and present
Standard conditionals stay in one time zone, whereas a mixed conditional links a past event to a present result, or an ongoing present state to a past result.
For a past condition with a present result, pair If + past perfect with would, could or might + base verb (or be + -ing): If Maya had chosen Spanish two years ago, she would be eligible for the Madrid exchange now.
For a present state with a past result, pair If + past simple with would, could or might have + past participle: If Leo weren't (or wasn't) so organised, he would never have met Monday's scholarship deadline. Both were and was are correct with I, he, she and it.
| Direction | If-clause | Result clause | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Past → present | if + had + past participle | would / could / might + base verb | If I had slept properly last night, I would feel sharper for my mock interview today. |
| Present → past | if + past simple | would / could / might have + past participle | If Nadia didn't speak Mandarin, the museum wouldn't have asked her to guide the visiting group yesterday. |
But for and should you…
But for + noun phrase (or -ing) means without in hypothetical conditionals. Look at the result clause to see whether it refers to the present or the past: But for the late bus into town, sixth-formers in our village would struggle to reach Saturday jobs (present). But for our teacher's encouragement, I would never have sent off my entry (past).
Should + subject + base verb replaces If + subject + should + base verb in polite, formal first conditionals, meaning if by any chance: Should you require any further details about my work experience, please contact my head of year. In the negative, never use a contraction: write Should you not be able to attend, let the organisers know.
The unreal past: it's time, would rather and as if
Just like wish, three everyday expressions shift the verb one step back into the past to show that something is not real right now or did not happen.
It's time, it's high time and it's about time + subject + past simple say that something is overdue and ought to happen soon: Term ends next Friday — it's high time we started revising! (It's time to start and It's time for us to start are also correct; use the past simple when a subject comes straight after time.)
Would rather ('d rather) takes a bare infinitive when the subject stays the same (I'd rather shadow a journalist than work in a shop). When you introduce a new subject, use the past simple for now or the future (I'd rather you came to the open day with me) and the past perfect for the past (I'd rather you had checked with me before booking that slot).
As if and as though mean the same. When a comparison is clearly untrue, use the past simple for an unreal present (He orders everyone around as if he ran the whole place!) and the past perfect for an unreal past (She carried on presenting as though the projector hadn't just switched itself off). When something may genuinely be true, use a normal present tense: Judging by the queue outside the bakery, it looks as if they need extra weekend staff.
- Owen:
- Have you chosen your subjects for next year yet? It's about time I made up my mind, and I'm still torn between history and computer science.
- Priya:
- Honestly, if I hadn't spent a week at a local radio station in March, I would still have no idea either. But for that placement, I'd never have discovered sound engineering.
- Owen:
- Lucky you! My older brother keeps lecturing me as though he knew every job on the planet. Frankly, I'd rather he let me work it out for myself.
- Priya:
- Well, the careers adviser is inside right now. Should you want a quiet chat without your brother hovering nearby, grab a seat at her table first!
Exercises
Press Check answers to see your score.